Supreme Court upholds SEBI's action against Kotak AMC, MD Nilesh Shah
August 3, 2026

On Monday, the Supreme Court upheld the Securities and Exchange Board of India’s (SEBI’s) findings against Kotak Mahindra Asset Management Company (Kotak AMC), its Managing Director Nilesh Shah, and other senior officials in the Essel Group Fixed Maturity Plan (FMP) case, holding them responsible for regulatory failures in managing the schemes.
A bench comprising Justices Dipankar Datta and Satish Chandra Sharma rejected the appeals filed by Kotak AMC, Kotak Trustee Company, and six senior executives. The court endorsed SEBI’s view that the fund house violated regulatory duties by allowing the tenure of certain debt securities to run beyond the schemes’ maturity dates without following the mandated framework, by not exercising sufficient due diligence, and by delaying compulsory disclosures to investors and the regulator.
The Supreme Court further ordered Kotak AMC to pay ₹30 lakh as litigation costs and Kotak Trustee to pay ₹20 lakh, while leaving intact the financial penalties that SEBI had already imposed.
The bench noted that the 1996 mutual fund regulations do not differentiate between violations that lead to profits and those that lead to losses. It stated that, since market integrity is paramount, whether investors gained or lost money is irrelevant when determining if a regulatory breach has occurred.
Ending the judgment with a wider message for the mutual fund ecosystem, the court remarked: “Mandate first, gains later; SEBI compliance, never falter.”
The case stems from investments totaling ₹266 crore made by six closed-ended Kotak Mutual Fund FMPs in zero-coupon non-convertible debentures issued by Essel Group entities Konti Infrapower & Multiventures and Edison Utility Works. These exposures were backed by pledged shares of Zee Entertainment Enterprises.
When the value of the pledged Zee shares fell sharply in 2019, Kotak AMC chose to restructure the debt instead of invoking the pledged collateral. As a result, a portion of the investments was repaid only after the schemes had already reached their scheduled maturity dates.
SEBI concluded that this effectively amounted to extending the schemes without investor approval and without following the regulatory norms applicable to rollovers.
Criticising the conduct of the appellants, the bench said that the way they dealt with the situation particularly their failure to keep investors, SEBI, and the court properly informed attracted the court’s “stern disapproval.”
The ruling effectively endorses the Securities Appellate Tribunal’s (SAT) March 2026 decision, which had confirmed SEBI’s findings on regulatory breaches and the penalties on the fund house and its officials.
However, SAT had earlier overturned SEBI’s direction that Kotak AMC should disgorge part of its investment management fees, taking into account that investors ultimately received their principal along with interest.
Related Posts
.png)
SEBI to roll out AI-use rules for capital markets with investor-protection guardrails
MFDs using AI-led tools for client communication or investment processes should prepare for SEBI’s upcoming guardrails on disclosures, accountability and human oversight.

SEBI forms panel to overhaul ICDR rules for IPOs, FPOs and QIPs
SEBI’s review of IPO/FPO/QIP rules could streamline disclosures and processes, potentially boosting primary market activity that impacts equity market sentiment and client interest.

Retail inflation jumps to 6.09% in October
CPI inflation crossing 6% raises the probability of an RBI rate hike, which can impact debt fund returns and client asset-allocation conversations.







