6 out of 10 discretionary equity PMS outperform benchmark: APMI

6 out of 10 discretionary equity PMS outperform benchmark: APMI

Majority of PMS Strategies Deliver Positive Alpha

More than half of India's discretionary equity Portfolio Management Services (PMS) have outperformed their respective benchmarks over the past five years, according to the latest data released by the Association of Portfolio Managers in India (APMI). The analysis shows that 57.6% of 543 discretionary equity PMS strategies generated positive alpha over the five-year period ending May 2026. In other words, nearly six out of every ten PMS strategies managed to beat their benchmark indices. On the other hand, 42.4% of PMS strategies underperformed their benchmarks, highlighting that while active management has added value for a majority of investors, consistent outperformance remains challenging across the industry.

Distribution of Alpha Generation

The study also provides insights into how PMS strategies were distributed based on their performance relative to benchmarks.

  • 57.6% generated positive alpha.
  • 42.4% underperformed their benchmarks.
  • 7.5% delivered alpha exceeding 10 percentage points.
  • Around 3% underperformed their benchmarks by more than 10 percentage points.

Discretionary Equity PMS Continues to Dominate the Industry

Discretionary equity PMS remains the largest segment within India's PMS industry. Under this model, portfolio managers make investment decisions on behalf of clients without requiring approval for every transaction. This category currently manages ₹4.12 lakh crore, accounting for 68.3% of the industry's total PMS Assets Under Management (AUM) of ₹6.03 lakh crore, excluding EPFO assets.

Top Alpha Generators Over Five Years

A significant gap exists between the two best-performing PMS strategies and the rest of the market.

1. Varanium Capital Advisors – Varanium G2G India Portfolio

  • Five-year return: 69.14%
  • Benchmark: Nifty 50 TRI
  • Alpha: 59.27%

2. Aequitas Investment Consultancy – Aequitas India Opportunities Product

  • Five-year return: 38.16%
  • Alpha: 28.29%

3. Green Lantern Capital – GLC Growth Fund

  • Five-year return: 34.86%
  • Alpha: 22.57%

Other Top-Performing PMS Strategies

S.No PMS Provider Strategy 5-Year Return Alpha
1 ICICI Prudential AMC India Recovery Strategy 34.78% 22.49%
2 Counter Cyclical Investments Diversified Long Term Value 32.56% 20.27%
3 ICICI Securities ISEC Aggressive Portfolio 31.98% 22.11%
4 Green Portfolio Super 30 Dynamic Fund 31.64% 19.35%
5 Nippon Life India AMC Emerging Sector Opportunity Portfolio 30.69% 18.40%
6 Seers Fund Management Seers Enduring Portfolio 30.53% 20.66%
7 New Berry Capitals Seeking Alpha Strategy 30.39% 22.86%

Several Established PMS Houses Also Posted Strong Alpha

Beyond the top ten, a number of established PMS providers generated double-digit alpha over the five-year period. These include:

  • Escorp Asset Management
  • Ghalla Bhansali Stock Brokers
  • Mittal Analytics
  • Dalal & Broacha Stock Broking
  • ICICI Prudential AMC (Infrastructure Strategy)
  • Green Portfolio (Dividend Yield Fund)
  • Wallfort Fund Management
  • Zen Wealth Management Services
  • Tulsian PMS

Benchmark Selection Matters When Comparing Alpha

Investors should exercise caution when comparing alpha across PMS strategies because managers use different benchmark indices based on their investment approach.

While many PMS strategies are benchmarked against the Nifty 50 TRI or BSE 500 TRI, others use indices such as the MSEI SX40 TRI. Since alpha is calculated relative to the chosen benchmark, direct comparisons between different PMS strategies may not always be meaningful.

‍

Table Of Contents
Table Of Contents
videos

Related Posts

MFD Daily
India's ETF industry crosses  ₹10 lakh crore AUM as ETF apps gain attention
July 31, 2026

India's ETF industry crosses ₹10 lakh crore AUM as ETF apps gain attention

Rapid growth in India’s ETF AUM and app-based access signals a structural shift toward low-cost passive products that MF distributors must factor into their product mix and client conversations.

MFD Daily
HDFC Mid Cap Fund joins the Rs 1 lakh crore club. Here are India's biggest mutual funds
August 3, 2026

HDFC Mid Cap Fund joins the Rs 1 lakh crore club. Here are India's biggest mutual funds

HDFC Mid Cap Fund’s entry into the ₹1 lakh crore AUM club, with strong 3–5 year returns, reinforces the case for mid-cap equity as a core growth option in MF distributors’ client portfolios—provided suitability and long-term track record are evaluated carefully.

MFD Daily
Your ARN number is now accepted for Meta ads verification
July 31, 2026

Your ARN number is now accepted for Meta ads verification

Meta now accepting ARN for ad verification lets MFDs run compliant, more credible campaigns on Facebook and Instagram, strengthening investor trust and regulatory alignment.

MFD Daily
ICICI Prudential launches Multi-Asset Active FoF: Key details for investors
July 31, 2026

ICICI Prudential launches Multi-Asset Active FoF: Key details for investors

This multi-asset FoF offers MFDs a single-product solution to position diversified, actively managed asset allocation across equity, debt, gold and silver for clients seeking smoother long-term outcomes.

MFD Daily
IRDAI proposes public mis-selling records, commission clawback to curb insurance sales malpractice
September 25, 2026

IRDAI proposes public mis-selling records, commission clawback to curb insurance sales malpractice

IRDAI’s proposed anti–mis-selling rules could sharply tighten accountability, disclosure and commission practices for anyone distributing insurance alongside investment products to clients.

MFD Daily
MFD Daily
IRDAI proposes public mis-selling records, commission clawback to curb insurance sales malpractice
21 Dec 2025

IRDAI proposes public mis-selling records, commission clawback to curb insurance sales malpractice

IRDAI’s proposed anti–mis-selling rules could sharply tighten accountability, disclosure and commission practices for anyone distributing insurance alongside investment products to clients.

MFD Daily
Mutual Fund AUM-to-bank deposit ratio triples in a decade to 31% in August
21 Dec 2025

Mutual Fund AUM-to-bank deposit ratio triples in a decade to 31% in August

Rapid growth in mutual fund AUM versus bank deposits signals a structural shift in household savings that MFDs can tap into for higher market-linked allocations.

MFD Daily
Kotak Alts closes Rs 5,000-crore Yield & Growth Fund with domestic capital
21 Dec 2025

Kotak Alts closes Rs 5,000-crore Yield & Growth Fund with domestic capital

Kotak Alts’ fully domestically funded Rs 5,000-crore Yield & Growth AIF highlights growing local appetite for private credit and real-asset strategies that can complement client portfolios beyond traditional mutual funds.

MFD Daily
Aditya Birla Sun Life MF reopens three international funds from September 24
21 Dec 2025

Aditya Birla Sun Life MF reopens three international funds from September 24

Aditya Birla Sun Life MF’s reopening of three international schemes with a Rs 1 crore per PAN per day cap creates fresh overseas allocation opportunities that MFDs can position for clients within defined limits.

MFD Daily
State-wise SIP Trends Reflect India's Expanding Mutual Fund Industry: AMFI Annual Report FY26
21 Dec 2025

State-wise SIP Trends Reflect India's Expanding Mutual Fund Industry: AMFI Annual Report FY26

State-wise SIP and retail AUM trends signal a deeper, more broad-based opportunity set for mutual fund distributors beyond traditional metros.

MFD Daily